Medicaid Recipients Can Keep More of Award Due to Deal

If you are injured due to medical malpractice or because of another person's negligence, you could receive care through your state's Medicaid program. In such cases, the state has a legal right to recover funds from your personal injury award or settlement to reimburse it for the care it provided.

Personal Injury Settlements

Awards or settlements can cover not just medical expenses, but things like lost wages, pain and suffering, and permanent disability. But what portion of an award or settlement can go to the state – only the portion allocated for medical expenses, or the entire amount if that is what is needed to fully reimburse Medicaid? The new congressional budget deal finally clarifies the situation.

First a little background. Prior to 2006, some states had been claiming from victims more than just that part of an award or settlement covering medical expenses. In some cases, states would claim that the entire settlement was theirs, no matter how much of it was earmarked for medical expenses. 

For example, say Medicaid paid $300,000 for an injured person’s care. The eventual settlement amount was $500,000, of which $150,000 was allocated for medical expenses and $350,000 for lost wages and pain and suffering. Some states could get back the entire $300,000 in Medicaid payments, leaving the injured person with only $200,000, even though the settlement itself stipulated that only $150,000 was for the payment of medical expenses.

Supreme Court Decision of 2006 and Its 2013 Negation

In a 2006 decision, the U.S. Supreme Court unanimously ruled that states can only recover their costs from the portion of a Medicaid recipient's settlement that is specifically allocated to medical expenses, leaving the remaining settlement funds untouched. The case was Arkansas Department of Health and Human Services, et al. v. Ahlborn, 547 U.S. 268 (2006).

However, in 2013 Congress effectively negated the Supreme Court’s ruling by amending the Social Security Act to give states the right to recover from Medicaid beneficiaries' entire awards or settlements. The law granted state Medicaid programs the right to fully recover their medical costs before plaintiffs could receive any recovery for lost wages, non-economic damages, or any other type of recovery. The new law also gave states the right to place a lien on awards or settlements.

From 2013 Onward

Since 2013, the American Association for Justice (AAJ) (formerly the American Trial Lawyers Association) has fought to eliminate the provision. It managed to twice delay implementation of the new law – first to October 2016, and then again to October 2017. Ever since last October’s delay expired, the AAJ has worked for the law’s repeal. It finally achieved this in the budget deal signed into law by President Trump on February 9, 2018.

This means that the Supreme Court’s 2006 interpretation of Medicaid law returns as the law of the land. State Medicaid programs can claim against only that portion of an award or settlement that is earmarked for medical expenses. This means that more funds of those who have been injured by malpractice or negligence can go into instruments like special needs trusts to help the beneficiaries throughout their lives. (Some states may further limit their own Medicaid agency's right to recover against an award or settlement.  California, for example, permits collection only up to 50 percent of an award.)

"We believe this is a great victory that will ensure Medicaid recipients retain access to the courts,” said Linda Lipsen, AAJ’s Chief Executive Officer.