Medicaid Work Requirements Ruling Favors Disabled Recipients

TakeawaysStressed older man in a wheelchair sits with his head in his hands

  • A federal judge ruled that the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) “significantly impairs” test for Medicaid expansion's medically frail exemption was beyond CMS’s authority.

  • This could positively affect people with disabilities facing Medicaid work requirements.

  • The work requirements and their January 1, 2027 deadline (some states started earlier) in place, along with the 12-month medical records look-back and the one-time self-attestation limit.

  • The decision can still be appealed, so people with disabilities should gather recent medical records and ask their state Medicaid agency how it will verify medical frailty.

A federal judge in Boston ruled that the federal government’s definition of “medically frail” under new Medicaid work requirements went beyond what Congress allowed. This decision could have important implications for those who fall under this exemption, including adults with disabilities. 

However, it leaves the work requirements themselves in place, and it did not strike down every rule the suing states challenged. This ruling comes from a single federal trial court and is not necessarily the final word. The government can appeal, and a related case is still pending in another court.

Local Special Needs Planners in Your City

Planner name

Firm Name
City, State

Planner name

Firm Name
City, State

Planner name

Firm Name
City, State

Still, it's important to understand how these rules are evolving as they come into effect January 1, 2027.

Background: The New Medicaid Requirement

In July 2025, H.R. 1, otherwise known as the One Big Beautiful Bill Act, was passed into federal law. As part of this act, adults covered through Medicaid expansion will need to show they work, volunteer, or attend school starting no later than January 1, 2027. Some states were allowed to begin earlier, and a state showing good-faith effort can get a temporary delay (no later than December 31, 2028).

The standard is 80 hours of these activities per month, or monthly income equal to 80 hours at the federal minimum wage. The law exempts several groups, including people who are deemed to be too medically frail to meet the work requirements. Congress listed examples of who is exempt from the requirement:

  • People who are blind or disabled

  • People with a substance use disorder

  • People with a disabling mental disorder

  • People with a physical, intellectual, or developmental disability that significantly impairs their ability to perform one or more activities of daily living

  • People with a serious or complex medical condition

In June 2026, the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) issued an interim final rule adding new limits, including:

  • An exemption only applies if the applicant's condition “significantly impairs” their ability to meet the work requirement

  • That states could only look back 12 months in medical records to verify medical frailty status

  • That a person could self-attest to being medically frail only once per enrollment period, starting January 1, 2028

Twenty-five states and the District of Columbia sued CMS. They challenged only parts of CMS’s rule, not the work requirements themselves.

The states argued that CMS added hurdles Congress never approved and that the changes could cost eligible people their coverage. Congress already spelled out who counts as “medically frail,” and the states argued an agency can’t add extra requirements. The states challenged three parts of the rule: the “significantly impairs” test, the 12-month look-back, and the limit on self-attestation.

The states also argued that the rule unfairly pressured them with unclear requirements, without giving them time to prepare.

What the Judge Decided

  • The “significant impairment” test is out. Judge Richard Stearns found that CMS could not shrink the floor set by Congress regarding who counts as medically frail. He erased that part of the rule and ordered CMS not to enforce it.

  • Two CMS limits remain. The judge found the 12-month look-back and the one-time self-attestation limit were not unreasonable.

  • Plaintiff states get a six-month grace period. Because states must quickly change their verification systems, the court granted them six months of relief from enforcement over medically frail determinations.

  • The work requirements and start date remain. The January 1, 2027, start date is unchanged by the court decision.

What This Means for People With Disabilities

The work requirement applies only to adults ages 19 to 64 who receive Medicaid through the expansion group. This does not apply to people over the age of 65. It also doesn’t apply to people who get Medicaid through a disability pathway, such as those who receive SSI. That means many people with significant disabilities are not subject to the requirement at all.

The ruling most affects people with disabilities or serious health conditions who get Medicaid through expansion instead. This can include adults who haven’t yet been approved for SSI or SSDI, people whose disability is newly diagnosed or hard to document, and people with chronic conditions who don’t meet Social Security’s strict definition of disability.

For them, the medically frail exemption may be the only thing protecting their coverage. Advocates warned CMS’s “significantly impaired” requirement could cost eligible people their coverage — even if they fell under an exemption.

With the extra test gone, a person who fits one of the five groups no longer has to prove that their condition also stops them from working, though the disability group must still meet the statute’s own daily-living standard. For many people with disabilities, that removes a vague hurdle that could have varied state to state.

Applicants with disabilities should still take care. Paperwork still matters and the remaining limits could make it harder to prove frailty. This is especially true for someone with a recent diagnosis or few recent medical records.

Is This Ruling Final?

This was a decision by one federal district judge in Massachusetts, and several things could still change the outcome.

  • It applies broadly but can be appealed. The judge set aside the “significant impairment” test and ordered CMS not to enforce it. The agency could still appeal, which would send the case to the First Circuit Court of Appeals and possibly the Supreme Court. CMS Administrator Mehmet Oz said on November 3 that the agency will appeal.

  • CMS could rewrite the rule to adhere to the judge's decision. Instead of appealing, the agency could try to change its policy in a way that addresses the judge’s concerns.

  • Another lawsuit is pending. A separate case on the same issue, Taylor v. Kennedy, is pending in federal court in Maryland. A different judge could reach a different conclusion.

  • The states did not overturn everything. The judge upheld the 12-month look-back and the one-time self-attestation limit. He also didn't pause the work requirements, which still begin January 1. Those parts are in effect unless a court says otherwise.

What To Do Now

The work requirements begin no later than January 1, 2027, so there is time to prepare. Most of the steps below come down to having the right paperwork ready. Even people who are exempt may have to prove it, so it’s better to get organized now than to scramble after a notice arrives.

  • Confirm which Medicaid category you or your family member is in. The work requirement applies only to the expansion group. It doesn’t apply to people enrolled through aged or disabled pathways, or through SSI or Medicare.

  • Check with your state Medicaid agency about how it will verify medical frailty and what documents it will accept.

  • Gather recent medical records, since only the past 12 months can be used for verification. Anyone with a recent diagnosis or few recent records should ask their doctors to document the condition now.

  • Use self-attestation carefully. Beginning January 1, 2028, states may accept it only once per enrollment period; ask your state how it handles it in 2027.

  • Watch your mail and online account for notices and respond quickly. Free legal aid and disability rights organizations can help.

  • Free legal aid, disability rights organizations, and special needs planning attorneys can help with exemptions and notices.

None of these steps requires waiting for the courts. Whether the ruling stands, gets appealed, or is replaced by a new rule, having a file of current records is vital.

Additional Reading

For additional reading on issues related to Medicaid, check out the following articles:


Created date: 11/17/2026

Topics

View All Special Needs Topics Questions & Answers Directory of Pooled Trusts Directory of ABLE Accounts